Career Growth Starts Here

View current openings and submit your application

Payroll and Benefits Administrator

Milwaukee, WI

Posted: 10/21/2025 Employment Type: Temp to Hire Industry: Account Manager Pay Rate: 28

Job Description

Payroll & Benefits Administrator

Location: [Insert Location or “Remote/Hybrid Available”]
Department: Human Resources
Employment Type: Full-Time

About the Role

We are seeking a Payroll & Benefits Administrator to support day-to-day HR operations and ensure an exceptional employee experience. This position manages payroll and benefits processing, employee inquiries, and leave administration with a focus on accuracy, compliance, and empathy. This is a great opportunity for someone who thrives in a fast-paced environment, enjoys problem-solving, and takes pride in delivering detail-oriented, people-focused HR support.

What You’ll Do

  • Payroll & Benefits Administration:
  • Process and maintain all benefit enrollments, changes, and terminations.
  • Administer wellness and eligibility files, COBRA events, and vendor updates.
  • Coordinate with benefit and payroll vendors to ensure accurate employee data and deductions.
  • Employee Support & Communication:
  • Respond to approximately 50 daily inquiries from employees via the shared HR inbox.
  • Use discretion and sound judgment when deciding between email or phone communication.
  • Provide empathetic, accurate, and timely responses to benefits and payroll questions.
  • Leave of Absence (LOA) Coordination:
  • Manage all administrative aspects of employee leave programs.
  • Partner with third-party FMLA vendors to track cases and maintain accurate documentation.
  • Ensure compliance with federal, state, and institutional leave policies.
  • Compliance & Data Accuracy:
  • Maintain data integrity within HR systems and ensure compliance with all regulations.
  • Conduct regular audits to verify accuracy of benefits, deductions, and eligibility files.
  • Partner with HR leadership to resolve discrepancies and streamline workflows.
  • System & Vendor Management:
  • Utilize HRIS platforms (UKG preferred) to manage employee benefit and payroll data.
  • Collaborate with benefit carriers, leave vendors, and HR team members to optimize processes.

What You Bring

Required:

  • 3+ years of experience in payroll and benefits administration.
  • Strong understanding of benefit plans, COBRA, and leave administration.
  • Excellent attention to detail, accuracy, and confidentiality.
  • Effective communication and customer service skills.

Preferred:

  • Experience with UKG (or similar HRIS system).
  • Prior work with FMLA vendors and/or higher education institutions.
  • Familiarity with wellness and eligibility file management.

Who You Are

  • Empathetic & patient: Supports employees with care and professionalism.
  • Organized & detail-driven: Handles complex data and multiple priorities seamlessly.
  • Adaptable: Thrives in an environment with shifting needs and systems.
  • Collaborative: Works well across HR functions to deliver cohesive support.

How You’ll Succeed

  • Accurately process payroll and benefits with minimal errors.
  • Ensure timely and compliant leave administration.
  • Deliver clear and empathetic communication to all employees.
  • Contribute to improved HR efficiency and reduced administrative burden for leadership.

Hiring Process

  • Resume Review
  • Initial Virtual Interview with HR Management
  • Team Interview with Benefits & Leave Support Staff
  • Final Interview with HR Director (Virtual or In-Person)

Start Date: Flexible — hiring for the right fit.

Why Join Us

You’ll be part of a collaborative, professional HR team that values accuracy, empathy, and follow-through. This role offers the opportunity to make a tangible impact on both employee experience and organizational effectiveness.

Meet Your Recruiter

James Fletcher
Account Manager

Hi there! Searching for a new job is hard; let me make it easier. I love Milwaukee and have deep connections with this city. I recently shifted career paths and have a passion for helping you do the same thing. What are you waiting for? Let's go!

Send an email reminder to:

Share This Job:

Related Jobs:

Login to save this search and get notified of similar positions.

About Milwaukee, WI

Ready to kickstart your career in the vibrant region around Milwaukee, Wisconsin? Embrace endless growth opportunities and unbeatable charm in this bustling city along Lake Michigan. From the mesmerizing Milwaukee Art Museum to the pulsating energy of the Harley-Davidson Museum, this area offers a blend of cultural experiences and bustling city life. Indulge in delectable cheese curds and custard, catch a show at the historic Pabst Theater, or cheer on the Brewers at American Family Field. Discover your next career move while soaking up the area's unique culture and charm. Explore our job listings today and take your career to new heights in Milwaukee, Wisconsin!